The Supreme Court is asked to hear a case about same-sex adoptions.(Photo: AP)
WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court on Monday unanimously reversed an Alabama court's refusal to recognize a same-sex adoption.
The justices upheld a challenge brought by an Alabama woman after her state's highest court refused to recognize the<span style="color: Red;">*</span>adoption she and her former lesbian partner were granted in Georgia.
The couple never married and have since<span style="color: Red;">*</span>split up. But the case presented a test of an issue that crops up occasionally in state and federal courts since the Supreme Court struck down state bans on same-sex marriage: Can gays and lesbians be denied adoption rights?
The case was brought by "V.L.," as she is identified in court papers, against her former partner "E.L.," who gave birth to three children between 2002-04 while the couple was together.<span style="color: Red;">*</span>To win<span style="color: Red;">*</span>adoption rights for V.L., they<span style="color: Red;">*</span>established temporary residency in<span style="color: Red;">*</span>Georgia.
Now that they have split,<span style="color: Red;">*</span>E.L. agreed<span style="color: Red;">*</span>with the Alabama Supreme Court, which ruled in September that Georgia mistakenly granted V.L. joint custody. E.L.'s lawyers argued that<span style="color: Red;">*</span>"the Georgia court had no authority under Georgia law to award such an<span style="color: Red;">*</span>adoption, which is therefore void and not entitled to full faith and credit."
Not so, the Supreme Court ruled. "A state may not disregard the judgment of a sister state because it disagrees with the reasoning underlying the judgment or deems it to be wrong on the merits," its reversal said. Rather, Alabama must give "full faith and credit" to the Georgia court's decision.
The high court previously had<span style="color: Red;">*</span>blocked the Alabama court's action while considering the case, temporarily restoring V.L.'s visitation rights.
Adoption rights for same-sex couples are among the issues remaining in the wake of the high court's June decision legalizing same-sex marriage.<span style="color: Red;">*</span>About 30 states grant "second-parent adoptions" to<span style="color: Red;">*</span>gay and lesbian couples by law or lower court rulings. Such adoptions benefit<span style="color: Red;">*</span>adults who do not share a biological connection,<span style="color: Red;">*</span>while ensuring<span style="color: Red;">*</span>that children have two legal parents -- particularly in case one dies or is incapacitated.
Lawyers for V.L., including the<span style="color: Red;">*</span>National Center for Lesbian Rights,<span style="color: Red;">*</span>said<span style="color: Red;">*</span>the case has broad implications for any gay or lesbian adoptive parents who travel or move to Alabama.
“The Supreme Court’s reversal of Alabama’s unprecedented decision to void an adoption from another state is a victory not only for our client but for thousands of adopted families,” Cathy Sakimura, the center's family law director, said. “No adoptive parent or child should have to face the uncertainty and loss of being separated years after their adoption just because another state’s court disagrees with the law that was applied in their adoption.”
The case could affect other states that challenge or deny same-sex adoptions, according to a brief submitted by adoption and child welfare agencies.
"While at least 30 states have permitted second-parent adoptions, almost all of them have done so under statutory frameworks that, like Georgia’s, do not expressly embrace the concept," the brief says. "As a result, the number of children who could be adversely affected by the Alabama Supreme Court’s decision is large."
The lawyers told the justices in court papers that same-sex adoptions "have been granted<span style="color: Red;">*</span>since at least the mid-1980s, long before same-sex couples could marry." They estimated that hundreds of thousands of such adoptions now exist.
The most recent statistics from the<span style="color: Red;">*</span>Williams Institute at UCLA indicate an estimated 65,000 adopted children live with a lesbian or gay parent.
Powered By WizardRSS.com | Full Text RSS Feed