Luke Skywalker
Super Moderator
{vb:raw ozzmodz_postquote}:
Voters in Texas wait in line to cast their ballots last November.(Photo: Tamir Kalifa, AP)
WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court agreed Tuesday to decide whether state legislative districts must have roughly equal numbers of legal voters rather than overall populations.
The case was filed by voters in Texas who claim their ballots carry less weight than those of voters whose state Senate districts include large numbers of illegal immigrants.
While the Constitution is intended to protect the principle of one-person, one-vote, what remains unclear is whether districts must be apportioned based on the number of residents or the number of legal voters.
In states such as Texas, Arizona and California, where the number of illegal immigrants varies from one district to the next, drawing districts based on total population means that voters in one district will have less clout than those in the next.
In the Texas case, for instance, Sue Evenwel's mostly rural district has about 584,000 citizens eligible to vote, while a neighboring urban district has only 372,000. As a result, voters in the urban district have more sway to influence the outcome.
A federal district court in Texas ruled that the state Legislature's use of total population could not be appealed. But as far back as 2001, at least one justice, Clarence Thomas, had said the issue should be reviewed by the Supreme Court.
The two voters challenging the state Senate maps claimed in their petition to the high court that in theory, the legislature could have put one voter in each of 30 Senate districts and all the state's other voters into the 31st. (Such a plan would have trouble meeting other requirements, such as geographic contiguity.)
"The one-person, one-vote principle, by its terms, entitles voters to an equal vote," the challengers said. "Unless the districting process no longer protects that right, the judgment below cannot stand."
The organization behind the challenge, the Project on Fair Representation, also was the brainchild of other major Supreme Court cases challenging minority preferences. Among them: Fisher v. University of Texas, challenging the use of affirmative action policies in college admissions, and Shelby County, Ala., v. Holder, challenging a major section of the Voting Rights Act.
The challengers were backed by a half-dozen conservative and libertarian groups, an unusually large number for a case that had yet to be granted by the high court. But it appears they were persuasive.
Texas responded that the justices have never required legislative districts to be drawn based on the number of voters, rather than total population. "Multiple precedents from this court confirm that total population is a permissible apportionment base under the Equal Protection Clause," the state said.
The case will be taken up during the court's next term, which begins in October.
VIDEO: THE DAY IN NEWSAerials show extent of historic Texas floods | 01:23Aerial footage of flooding in Houston shows completely submerged cars, water filled roads and even a man traveling by kayak. VPC
VIDEO: THE DAY IN NEWSBusy Houston roads flood, now look like rivers | 00:54Some secondary highways near Houston are filled with abandoned, flooded vehicles. VPC
VIDEO: THE DAY IN NEWSFlood kills homecoming queen driving home from prom | 01:18A Texas community is mourning a high school homecoming queen who was killed when flood waters overtook her car. Alyssa Ramirez was just two miles from her home. VPC
VIDEO: THE DAY IN NEWS'Shell No' protester hanging from anchor comes down | 01:22A "Shell No" protester who spent the weekend hanging from The Arctic Challenger came down without incident. Chiara D'Angelo said she wanted to raise awareness about climate change and the risks of offshore drilling. KING-TV
VIDEO: THE DAY IN NEWSIraq renews effort against Islamic State | 00:50Iraq announced Tuesday it is renewing efforts to drive the Islamic State from western Anbar province.
Without providing details, authorities said a new operation was being launched with Iraq troops supported by Shiite and Sunni forces.
The Islamic Wochit
VIDEO: THE DAY IN NEWSCharter buying Time Warner Cable for $55.3B | 01:23Charter Communications is buying Time Warner Cable for $55.33 billion, creating another U.S. TV and Internet giant. (May 26) AP
VIDEO: THE DAY IN NEWS35 people killed in Baltimore's deadliest May since '99 | 01:01According to police, 35 people have been killed this May in Baltimore, 9 alone over the Memorial Day Weekend. The spike in violence is happening in West Baltimore where Freddie Gray died in police custody earlier this year. VPC
VIDEO: THE DAY IN NEWSBounce house flies through the air, three children hurt | 00:42Authorities say three children were hurt after a waterspout made landfall at a Florida beach and sent an inflatable bounce house flying into the air. VPC
VIDEO: THE DAY IN NEWSGrandma of 3-year-old boy found dead in swing speaks | 01:30The grandmother of a three-year-old boy found dead at playground says her daughter would never do anything to hurt her son and must have had a mental break. She was found swinging the dead child for an 'unusual amount of time.' VPC
VIDEO: THE DAY IN NEWSDeadly flood sweeps away family: 'We know they're gone' | 01:26A Texas family of four were swept away by severe flood waters with only the father being able to escape. The victim's family has come to accept the likely outcome. VPC
VIDEO: THE DAY IN NEWSNew research may help prevent Alzheimer's | 02:08An ambitious study is testing if an experimental drug might help healthy but at-risk people stave off Alzheimer's. In addition to brain scans checking for amyloid build up, researchers are looking for tangles of a protein named tau. (May 26) AP
VIDEO: THE DAY IN NEWSHorses come back to Mackinac in rite of spring | 01:20Horses do the heavy lifting on Mackinac Island, hauling people and cargo across Michigan's car-less tourist hotspot. The animals spend the winters elsewhere in the state, making their way back to the island every spring via ferry. (May 26) AP
VIDEO: THE DAY IN NEWSCharter Communications makes deal for Time Warner Cable | 00:53Just weeks after Comcast's failed attempt to acquire Time Warner Cable, Charter confirms it's purchasing the second-largest cable and internet provider instead. The $79 billion deal boils down to $55.33 billion excluding debt. Wochit
VIDEO: THE DAY IN NEWSB.B. King's daughters claim closest aides poisoned him | 01:08Two B.B. King heirs who've been most outspoken about the blues legend's care in his final days are accusing King's two closest aides of poisoning him.
VIDEO: THE DAY IN NEWSBrides For Sale: Sham Marriages Rise in Europe | 02:26Police across Europe are trying to combat a new type of human trafficking. Each year, dozens of women from the poorer corners of eastern Europe are lured to the West for access to their European identity cards. (May 25) AP
VIDEO: THE DAY IN NEWSSkin Cancer: 5 myths debunked | 01:40May is melanoma awareness month. A dermatologist breaks down five popular skin cancer myths. VPC
VIDEO: THE DAY IN NEWSTake an inside look at life-changing brain surgery | 03:32A Colorado man undergoes deep brain stimulation to help him deal with his Parkinson's disease. VPC
VIDEO: THE DAY IN NEWSWhere jailed reporter's trial fits in US-Iran relationship | 01:47Iranian news outlets say the trial of Washington Post reporter Jason Rezaian is set for May 26, two months before a nuclear deal deadline.
Video provided by Newsy Newsy
VIDEO: THE DAY IN NEWSUSPS stamps honor Medal of Honor recipients | 01:06Gary Beikirch, a Medal of Honor recipient, attended a Memorial Day ceremony in Washington, D.C., where USPS unveiled a postage stamp recognizing his military service during the Vietnam War. VPC
VIDEO: THE DAY IN NEWSSuspected would-be carjacker wasn't expecting THIS | 01:24Man held at gun point after alleged attempted robbery says his side of story is being ignored. VPC
VIDEO: THE DAY IN NEWSGeorgia's first quintuplets graduate high school | 01:25The graduation at North Oconee High School marks a first for the state of Georgia because the state's famous quintuplets received their diploma. VPC
VIDEO: THE DAY IN NEWSU.S. Military Escorts Air France Flight After Anonymous Threat | 01:07U.S. military jets escorted an Air France airliner to New York's Kennedy Airport after a threat was made against the flight. Wochit
VIDEO: THE DAY IN NEWSTown hopes fake orca will fix their sea lion problem | 01:02A desperate Oregon community is hoping an unlikely hero will help them get rid of their sea lion problem. They're bringing in a fake orca in hopes of scaring the unwanted animals away. KING
VIDEO: THE DAY IN NEWS93-year-old veteran finally gets his diploma | 03:12At one high school graduation, they celebrated both the future and the past. In addition to the seniors in cap and gown, was a senior citizen. VPC
VIDEO: THE DAY IN NEWSAerial views show massive storm damage in Houston | 02:04Fly over an apartment complex that collapsed from high winds in Houston. The area's been hit by severe weather and heavy rain. VPC
VIDEO: THE DAY IN NEWSFamily breaks down after not guilty verdict for Brelo | 00:49Family members of Timothy Russell and Malissa Williams spoke out after police officer Michael Brelo was found not guilty of voluntary manslaughter. Brelo shot and killed the pair after a high-speed chase. VPC
VIDEO: THE DAY IN NEWSNew Orleans housing officer shot, killed in cruiser | 01:27According to police, a Housing Authority of New Orleans officer was found shot to death inside his police cruiser early Sunday morning. WWL
VIDEO: THE DAY IN NEWS'A Beautiful Mind' mathematician, wife killed in crash | 01:21John Nash, whose life was portrayed in the movie 'A Beautiful Mind,' was killed in a car crash on the New Jersey turnpike, along with his wife Alicia. VPC
VIDEO: THE DAY IN NEWSDoctors, pharmacists nabbed in huge prescription drug bust | 00:46"Operation Pilluted," the largest prescription drug operation in DEA history, led to the arrests of 280 people in Arkansas, Louisiana, Alabama and Mississippi. Agents referred to the doctors, nurses and pharmacists involved as "drug dealers." VPC
Last VideoNext Video
Powered By WizardRSS.com | Full Text RSS Feed