Hey guys, I was sent here from a thread that discussed the closing of spam hammer. The premium version of Spam Hammer was working very well for me on a REALLY large forum, but I wasn't comfortable relying on something that now has nobody standing behind it, so I decided to give all of these add ons a try. While they haven't worked as well as Spam Hammer (I've had 6 or 7 spam registrations since installing yesterday afternoon), they are performing pretty well.
"Ban Spiders" and "Prevent Hostname and user agent from registering" do nothing without the definitions lists provided. "Rename register.php" isn't worth a crap at all, if you use the word 'register' or any variation of it, in your new name for the file. That totally defeats the purpose of that mod.
Any spammer who gets through "Spambot Stopper" would assuredly have gotten through "Spam Hammer." Neither are designed to stop human spammers and neither works all that well against bots if you have the timer setting too low. I recommend 25 seconds as a starting point, and only ever go up - not down - as adjustment. Lower timer numbers just help the spammers since the timer mod relies on pageload speeds - and a good many of the botnet admins use terrible proxies.
I am the person who originally paid to have "Spam Hammer" coded and I stopped recommending it long ago - due to the demonstrated instability of the coder of it, and due to his addition of some 'features' that are self defeating, such as the visible countdown timer before clicking 'submit' and the 'gotcha' messages to spammers upon rejection.. Both of these should be disabled unless you simply enjoy tipping off spammer botnet admins that you're using a timer.
I'm beginning to think there is no way to have ZERO spam.
The occasional human spammer CAN rarely get through, it's the nature of the web. But we have a answer for that as well, in development. Our attitude about this is militant - we DO believe all spam can and will be stopped. We don't start out, thinking it can't be done and therefore we must compromise. That's defeatist. It CAN be done and yes it HAS been done. My own sites, and five others I have personally secured for others, get NO spam despite 1000s of documented attempts.
So, on using the mods recommended in the OP here, please make sure that:
- "Register.php" has nothing in it that contains the word, 'register' or any variation of it. You'd be surprised how often I see this.
- "Ban spiders by user agent" contains the definitions list provided here
- "Prevent hostname and user agent from registering" contains the definitions list provided here
- "Spambot stopper" has 25 seconds as the timer setting, and also has the 'gotcha' and the visible countdown timer, disabled.
These Mods are only as good as the settings, like most everything else.